Introduction
Human resources (HR) is an intricate field, characterized by a multitude of responsibilities that contribute significantly to an organization’s performance. One of the primary functions of HR is recruiting, an area in which interviews play a crucial role. The nature and format of these interviews can profoundly impact the reliability of the results and, ultimately, the quality of the candidate selected for a position.
Two commonly employed interview formats are structured and unstructured interviews. There is a growing consensus among HR professionals that structured interviews, if adhered to correctly, are a superior, more professional format, resulting in a more reliable evaluation and comparison of candidates.
The Art and Science of Structured Interviews
To qualify as a structured interview, the format must meet three essential criteria. Firstly, all applicants should be asked the same set of questions, ensuring consistency across the evaluation process. Secondly, a common rating system must be used to evaluate responses. Lastly, the nature of the questions must be pertinent to the role applied for.
Regrettably, many HR professionals only partially comply with these standards, commonly asking the same set of questions but frequently neglecting to apply a consistent rating system or maintaining relevance in the interview questions. Unstructured elements can creep into the interview process, introducing potential biases and errors that can skew the results and compromise the fairness of the selection process.
Interviews should commence with introductions, followed by a comprehensive summary of the discussion’s expected trajectory. Providing a question period for the candidate allows them to clarify their understanding and demonstrate their thought process. The interview should conclude with a determination of the candidate’s fit for the role.
The Role of Conflict, Bias, and Stress in the Interview Process
Conflict and stress are inherent aspects of interviews, given the high stakes and the candidates’ need to demonstrate competence under scrutiny. However, these elements should be managed effectively to ensure fairness and reduce unnecessary discomfort.
Similarly, HR professionals should be aware of the potential biases that can influence their judgment during the interview process. These can include ‘similarity bias’ (favoring those who resemble the interviewer), ‘physical attractiveness bias,’ and the ‘halo effect’ (allowing one positive trait to overshadow other aspects of the candidate). These biases can lead to unfair treatment of candidates and undermine the reliability of the selection process.
In addition, ‘negative information through the grapevine’ can also taint the interview process. Recruiters must be careful to focus on objective data and avoid being influenced by unverified rumors or stereotypes.
Using Conflict Strategically in Interviews
Conflict, when managed strategically, can be a valuable tool during an interview process. It can be used to test a candidate’s conflict resolution skills, negotiation abilities, adaptability, and stress management competencies. Hypothetical scenarios or role-plays can be particularly effective in this regard, providing valuable insights into the candidate’s potential performance under real-life situations.
However, care should be taken to ensure that such scenarios do not escalate to extreme levels of tension or conflict, which could potentially distress the candidate and compromise the overall assessment’s validity.
High Stakes and High-Performance Team Management
The interview process represents high stakes negotiations, not just for the candidate but also for the organization. The success of a team, and ultimately the company, often depends on recruiting the right mix of competencies, abilities, and interpersonal skills.
Particularly in high-performance team management, managers need to continually monitor and address skill deficiencies. This includes investing in employees through training and development programs, leveraging new technology platforms, and promoting professional development. Ensuring a team’s competence and adaptability helps bridge any skills gap that could hinder an organization’s performance.
Relevance to the Current Marketplace
Considering the evolving nature of commerce and the marketplace, HR professionals need to be aware of the changing demands of different roles and industry sectors. This understanding should guide the development of interview questions and rating systems to ensure that they remain relevant and applicable.
Given the technology skills gap in regions like Canada and the USA, interviews should be designed to test technical skills alongside soft skills and interpersonal capabilities. Labour market information and research should be used to guide this process, ensuring that the selection process aligns with market needs and trends.
Conclusion
Structured interviews, when conducted correctly, can greatly enhance the reliability and fairness of the selection process. HR professionals need to consider numerous factors, including conflict management, bias mitigation, stress management, and continually evolving market needs.
Ensuring a consistent, relevant, and fair interview process does not merely benefit the candidates; it contributes to building a competent, adaptable, and high-performing workforce. As such, HR professionals should strive for continual improvement and refinement of their interview processes, seeking ongoing training and education to stay abreast of the latest trends and best practices in the field.
In a rapidly changing commercial environment, the role of HR is becoming increasingly important. Effective, structured interviewing processes are a vital part of this evolving landscape, helping to ensure the selection of the best talent for each role and contributing to the overall success of organizations.
Related books and resources:
“Who: The A Method for Hiring” by Geoff Smart and Randy Street – This book provides a definitive guide to hiring strategy, emphasizing the importance of structured interviews in finding the right candidates.
“High-Impact Interview Questions: 701 Behavior-Based Questions to Find the Right Person for Every Job” by Victoria A. Hoevemeyer – This book aids HR professionals and managers in creating and utilizing structured, behaviour-based interview questions that align with the job’s actual demands.
“Work Rules!: Insights from Inside Google That Will Transform How You Live and Lead” by Laszlo Bock – While not exclusively about interviewing, this book offers valuable insights into Google’s data-driven HR practices, including their approach to hiring and structured interviewing.
“The Essential Guide for Hiring & Getting Hired” by Lou Adler – This work is designed for both HR professionals and candidates, offering a perspective on the performance-based hiring process which relies on structured interviewing.
“Hiring for Attitude: A Revolutionary Approach to Recruiting and Selecting People with Both Tremendous Skills and Superb Attitude” by Mark Murphy – This book explores the importance of evaluating both skills and attitude in candidates, pertinent to structured interviews focusing on behavioural and situational questions.
“The Best Team Wins: Build Your Business Through Predictive Hiring” by Adam Robinson – This book discusses how to improve hiring processes, including the use of structured interviews to ensure the best team composition and performance.
“Performance-Based Hiring: How to Build a Winning Hiring System Including Interviewing, Selecting and Recruiting the Best” by Lou Adler – Another book by Lou Adler that delves deeper into the performance-based hiring methodology, advocating for structured interviews as part of a comprehensive hiring strategy.
“Evidence-Based Recruiting: How to Build a Company of Star Performers Through Systematic and Repeatable Hiring Practices” by Atta Tarki – This book emphasizes a systematic approach to hiring that includes structured interviewing techniques backed by evidence and research.
“Smart and Gets Things Done: Joel Spolsky’s Concise Guide to Finding the Best Technical Talent” by Joel Spolsky – Although focused on the tech industry, this book provides insights applicable to any sector, especially on the topic of identifying talent through effective interviewing techniques, including structured interviews.
To see our Donate Page, click https://skillsgaptrainer.com/donate
To see our YouTube Channel, click https://www.youtube.com/@skillsgaptrainer
To see our Instagram Channel, click https://www.instagram.com/skillsgaptrainer/
To see some of our Udemy Courses, click SGT Udemy Page